Excerpt 3 - "Harry Potter & the Order of The Phoenix" by J.K. Rowling
Personally, I find originality an essential part of literature and without it a novel would lack any means of interesting me as a reader. However, excerpt 3 did not only have the scarce and appreciated ability to grab my attention as I began reading, it also achieved something far more important that other romantic tales fail to interpret; the act of presenting love as a believable and natural emotion, instead of exerting it as a perfect, unbelievable scenario. I resent it when romance has a “fairy – tale” structure because as readers we are all lost in a world of saintliness, while we all mutter exasperatedly under our breaths that life isn’t always a happy fantasy. On the other hand, “Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix” isn’t a romantic narrative, yet J.K. Rowling could have written the chapter as a clichéd epitome of “teenage love", but she used her imagination (not others!) to make this excerpt an enjoyable and pleasurable taster of what is to come next in the novel! Spellbindingly brilliant!
Flying With A Broken Wing
Francesca grasped the warm mug of cocoa in her hands, feeling the undulating water vapour embrace her tanned Italian skin. She placed the glass down onto the oak coffee table and picked up her best friend – her pocket mirror. She gazed at herself and saw a woman with an unblemished complexion: gracefully altering into her early forties. Sinuous lines of ageing spun their irreversible webs around her delicate under – eyes; a change not even her faithful Nivea Q10 Plus could amend. She rummaged into her Louis Vuitton handbag, thinking: So, this is what being an anatomical pathologist gives you; the finest handbags, the finest food - but not the one thing my life unconsciously skims over, not the one thing that gives a person a sense of living. Love. It’s being too close to the dead. It has murdered my primal instinct.
The thought reverberated in her mind, like the soul of a loved one echoing inside its bed for eternity. Its coffin.
A loved one. Death can be a lonely world, but a lonely existence can be far worse. A bit like walking a dead man’s road. No crossroads, no dead ends, just a tiring hike on the journey to a destination the living can’t answer. Heaven, hell – or just an unknown entity. Who knows?
Francesca looked up as Russell walked into the living room, precariously holding two plates of tortellini. He sported a grim expression whilst he carefully laid the dishes on the table.
“Thanks”.
Francesca smiled. She knew that there was nothing else that needed to be said. No idle chit – chat, no false laughter. Just silence. Nothing could be more honest than that. Francesca appreciatively allowed its reminiscent scent to float up her nostrils.
Is this the closest I am going to get to love? A famous Italian dish? It brings back so many childhood memories from Vercelli: Grandmother cordially smiling at me as I finished all my supper, me and Mia picking apricots and peaches in the blazing August heat; blood splattered over our kitchen wall, Mia’s lifeless body laying supine on the linoleum, her heartbeats losing their rhythmic pulse, while mine raced, beating a melody of disgust, anger and remorse –
“Francesca, are you eating that? Francesca?”
“Oh, sorry. I’m not really with it. I don’t feel too well.”
“I understand. Anybody would feel the same after what you have just gone through. Actually, I think you have coped with it pretty well.”
“You think so? I can’t help but feel pessimistic about her condition. I’ve lost too many people in my life. My sister, my mother, my father. Sandra is really close to me. If I lost her, I don’t think I could cope.
A disconsolate pause infused the atmosphere with an unbearable tension. She will survive, won’t she?” Russell looked straight into Francesca’s coffee coloured eyes and put his arm around her shoulder. She could feel his warmth radiating off him: his embrace was honest; comforting. It had felt like an eternity since someone had made her feel this way. She allowed his warm breath to brush against her skin – like a summer breeze gently swaying tulips in a deserted field. His skin was smooth, apart from the small shoots of stubble that had recently erupted from his skin.
“Of course she will. Sandra is in a stable condition. The medics said her survival chances are very high.”
“Thanks. I mean, everything you’ve done tonight. I am grateful.”
“Don’t worry about it. That’s what friends are for.”
Ah, friends. That’s all we’ll ever be.
Francesca tilted her head and moved closer. She couldn’t let this opportunity pass by. Her heart and stomach were fluttering simultaneously; nerves and excitement letting her inhibitions drip away. To Francesca’s surprise, Russell didn’t resist her first move. His pallid lips were so close, every second encapsulated an intensity Francesca had never felt before.
And the clock’s pendulum was the only thing that sang the truth . . .
Part One
ReplyDeleteI love your last comment, very apt! You pick up quite accurately that rather than relying upon a perfect representation of love, Rowling depicts a plausibly awkward teenage kiss. Te idea that Harry notices the tears on her eye-lashes is not a clichéd observation, but proves just how intense the moment is, he is taking in everything that he possibly can to preserve the kiss in his mind. It is true that though the masses quote openly “love isn’t a fairytale”, when investing their time in a novel or a film, they often choose the main stream romantic comedies with their obvious structure and happy endings! I’m glad you can see past this to the most interesting and feasible love stories.
Part Two
A really interesting opening to your story; for a moment I thought that you were going to delve into a story about a narcissist! That certainly would stray safely away from the cliché of love stories! However the route that you took was also interesting, someone unable to love, yet that longed to be able to do so. I thought that your switch between 1st and third person narration by taking advantage of italics. It really contrasts the awkwardness of the situation and the relationship with the deeper feelings that Fran exhibits.
It also explores the awkward decision to move a friendship further, this is an added level to the story which works really well, alongside the life-style choice between love and career. I feel that maybe you could work a little on your metaphors, just a little honing would improve them. For example, “She allowed his warm breath to brush against her skin – like a summer breeze gently swaying tulips in a deserted field”, the simile provides a contrast to what you are trying to describe, rather than a resemblance. A summer breeze is a nice relief from the hot sun: it is cool. However hot breath is predictable, unlike the breeze, and is warm against the cool air of the room. Just double check you are saying what you want to say with each of your metaphors.
I can see the vast improvement from your last piece of work. You have such a rich vocabulary, it is often hard not to put in as much as you can into a piece. It is hard to know what to select and what to omit from your piece, sometimes you have to be harsh! You really have proved that you can do it in this piece though. Continue to do this, you still have a little way to go before you master the balance. But on the whole, this is a beautiful piece! Well done.
Really, really well done. I’m glad, though depressing as it may be, you’ve approached a romance genre like this. I appreciate that you’ve seen J.K. Rowling’s non-fairytale love and used it as inspiration for your own. It’s realistic, love, or comfort, reveals itself in the most complex of situations – it’s not easy or perfect. And, though I’m not here to lecture you on love, I’m just really happy that you are seeing a side of it rarely shown. Though, on the other hand, I do hope there’s a bit of a Disney, head-over-heels kind of love story in your mind somewhere – it’s nice to be optimistic.
ReplyDeleteAnyway, away from my mild obsession with love.
I think you took the suggestions from the last task very well. As impressive as your vocabulary may be, I’m really happy to see that you’re experimenting with your style and that you feel comfortable with moderator’s suggestions.
The writing is wonderful; I can’t get over how much I love your final line. “And the clock’s pendulum was the only thing that sang the truth…” resonates so well in me; it’s ambiguous but reveals something in the last moment. It’s a perfect ending in my opinion.
I think that your story becomes stronger as it continues on; I think your introduction could be even stronger. It doesn’t seem as solid as other pieces in your story are. It almost seems too self pitying, whereas, for me, the rest doesn’t. Maybe gradually build into the tone, or set it up a little more relatable – if you understand at all what I’m trying to say.
Very well done though this week. I’m so glad you’re using some of the suggestions and you’re really motivated to get even better. That is the key to good writing.
Keep up the awesome work!